Thread:Turtle365/@comment-27270572-20140118070814/@comment-27270572-20140118193415

Well I will try then. This is my voting on Pinguinus's The Dragon of St. Romain story.

Plot: I hugely enjoyed the plot with the twists and turns. The Time war element and the Gargou story were truly brilliantly dealt with. The library bits were also epic and the timing did not feel rushed at all. Perfectly paced and nice reference to the Searing Daleks which will appear next series. I will rate this a perfect 10.

Originality: The gargoyles were not very original but with them coming from distant planets were awesome. The story was unique and I have seen nothing like it. Also the memory of the Gargoyle staying in everyone's minds to create the statues on churches was very original. I will have to rate this a high 9 because of the alien element and the medievel town with the disease and Time was plot.

Readability: The story was very easy to follow and the format made it very easy to follow the plot. So I wil rate this a very high 10 because of the format and the easy to follow plot.

Characterization: The Doctor and Jane were brilliantly betrayed and so was Romanus who felt genuinly from the 630's. The Gargou was brilliant and could not really improve. The conversation between the Doctor and Gargou were brilliant and Romanus's regret felt truly real. I will give this a 9 as the characters felt real and I could imagine being inside the story.

So overall I will rate this story an overly impressive 38 which is off the charts. his story definitely deserves it though and I cannot say much if anything about this epic adventure.