User blog comment:POMfannumber1/Davies VS. Moffat/@comment-27270572-20140419094134/@comment-27270572-20140425201610

Now for Davies episodes:

Rose. An enyoyable start to the series which uses the Autons well. There were some plot get outs but it was enjoyable but Mickey was a little too scared to be believable and the burbing bin? 8/10.

The End of the World. A gathering of races with plenty of killing in differing ways. None of the deaths brought up any emotions because most of the characters were under developed and the Face of Boe was not really used at all but that was building the mystery. 7/10.

Aliens of London/World War Three. The first part was actually quite good and intrigued me but then the farting Slitheen came along and ruined it, I mean why would they have farting aliens? A good start that ends badly. 7/10.

The Long Game. With Simon Pegg it should have been so good but was disappointing despite several good ideas that come off badly, Adam was made to be a terrible companion despite promise in Dalek. 6/10.

Boom Town. A boring episode in which hardly anything happens. The farting aliens return, the Slitheen, in a not very good appearance and it was just boring for me but the Doctor was awesome. 6/10.

Bad Wolf/The Parting of the Ways. The first part was not very good but that second part was just so good. The Daleks were awesome and Ecclestone was in top form this episode. His regeneration was brilliant with none of them 10 drama and the regeneration scene was brillaintly done. 9/10.

The Christmas Invasion. An enjoyable Christmas special with the 10th Doctor being introduced and the Sycorax this episode was cool. The spinning Christmas tree was terrible and we barely saw the Doctor actually doing anything for most of the episode. 7.5/10.

New Earth. The soppy love story between Ten and Rose began here and I hated it. The everyone lives thing was already done and more aliens with animal heads? I did enjoy some parts like the Lady Cassandra return. 7/10.

Tooth and Claw. The monks were cool and I really liked the werewolf. It was a very enjoyable episode despite the monks barely being used after the start, wasted potential, but a good episode all together. 8/10.

Love and Monsters. Worst episode ever. Well maybe that is too harsh as most of it was actually pretty good and the Doctor lite thing was good. Then the last 10 minutes with the Abzorbaloff   and the paving slob and what was suggested by what that guy does to it this episode really suffered in the last 10 minutes. 4/10.

Army of Ghosts/Doomsday. A brilliant two parter with the ghost reveal being brillaint. The Daleks v Cyberman battle was terrible with a one sided battle, it was boring to watch. I enjoyed the last part of the episode and although a death was promised and not actually there the ending was still emotional, that music at the end. 9/10.

The Runaway Bride. A boring Christmas special, Donna was really annoying here and I couldn't stand her but the Racnoss was awesome and needs to be reused and the Doctor's anger was brilliant. 7.5/10.

Smith and Jones. I liked Martha here and the Judoon have so much potential and this episode is just brilliant. The Doctor's solution was brilliant although the Judoon seemed to willing to kill to be the Intergalactic Space Police. 8/10.

Gridlock. The episode did go slowly but it was interesting with the traffic going on forever. The Face of Boe return was awesome and brilliant foreshadowing, YANA. The episode was slow in places. 7/10.

Utopia/The Sound of Drums/Last of the Time Lords. Utopia is the only part I liked out of the three with the shocking reveal of the Master, YANA. The solution to the three parter was terrible with people just saying Doctor and then he is cured, what? 7.5/10.

Voyage of the Damned. There were enjoyable moments with the women=ns sacrifice and death and the ending scene. The episode had really weird ideas like those angel people and the Titanic falling from the sky. 7/10.

Partners In Crime. A really like this episode with Donna being awesome and the funny moments being funny, I felt the efforts to be serious flopped to the ground but a very enjoyable story. 8/10.

Midnight. An absolutely brilliant episode with the excellent Midnight Entity and the exploration of how Humans would react. All the characters felt real and it had a relative of Patrick Troughton in it (son or grandson). 9.5/10.

Turn Left. This is a much more serious episode and it really pays off because of it, the exploration in a world without the Doctor is brilliantly done and the darker tones being excellent. 9/10.

The Stolen Earth/Journey End. The two parter was brilliant but had so many deux es machinas that is is ridiculous. The two parter is really fun and I enjoyed the companions returning. 8.5/10.

The Next Doctor. This was very intriguing and interesting for me until the Jackson Lake reveal and the Cybermen were underwhelming in this story, some good moments but mainly boring. 6.5/10.

Planet of the Dead. It tried to do what Midnight done but failed, miserbly. It was a fun episode with the one time companion and the scientist being played by Lee Evans being awesome but the episode was boring. 7/10.

The Waters of Mars. A brilliant co written episode with Series 8 writer Phil Ford. The creepy The Flood was awesome and the water zombies were awesome and very good and the Time Lord Victorious thing was very well done. 10/10.

The End of Time. A good two parter but it felt too big for 10's swansong. The Master came back in an unrealistic and impossible, from the DNA of his wifes lips two years after she shot him. I enjoyed the companions bit and 10 was awesome. 8/10.

As you can see I think Moffat is quite a bit better than Davies but they are both very good writers but Moffat is a lot better.